Irish Committee Proposes Ban on Services Linked to Israeli Settlements

A committee in Ireland has unanimously recommended the inclusion of services in a proposed ban on trade with illegal Israeli settlements. This decision comes from the Oireachtas Foreign Affairs Committee after hearing evidence from expert witnesses regarding the implications of such a ban. The report containing this recommendation is set to be published on March 6, 2024.

The Irish Government has stated its intention to legislate against the trade of goods linked to illegal Israeli settlements, following an advisory opinion from the International Court of Justice (ICJ). In a ruling last year, the ICJ urged countries to take action to prevent trade or investment that supports these settlements, which are deemed illegal under international law. While the opinion does not specify the types of trade involved, government officials have indicated that banning services presents more complex legal challenges.

Donnchadh Ó Laoghaire, a member of the committee and a representative of Sinn Féin, emphasized the importance of including services in the trade ban. He noted that this recommendation received “no push back” from any committee member, highlighting a consensus on the issue. The scope of the ban could potentially cover sectors such as finance, technology, and accommodation.

Ó Laoghaire stated, “Clearly, morally, the same issue arises whether it is goods or services; you’re still trading with illegal settlements that are undermining the potential for peace in the Middle East.” He expressed concern over the humanitarian crisis in Gaza, describing the situation as “human rights abuses upon human rights abuses.”

The recommendation has garnered support from various organizations, including Christian Aid Ireland. The charity’s head of policy, Conor O’Neill, called the committee’s decision “hugely significant.” He remarked, “Despite all the spin, misinformation and threats, TDs and senators from both Government and opposition spent weeks looking at the Occupied Territories Bill in detail, weighing up the evidence, hearing from experts and considering the impact.”

O’Neill further asserted, “They have said unequivocally: it is time to ban all trade with the illegal Israeli settlements, both goods and services, in line with international law.” He emphasized the importance of the committee’s stance, stating that any form of support, whether through importing goods or booking accommodations, contributes to the perpetuation of these settlements.

The Oireachtas Foreign Affairs Committee’s recommendation is seen as a critical step towards the passage of a comprehensive Occupied Territories Bill, which advocates for an immediate and effective ban on all trade linked to illegal settlements. As discussions continue, the Irish Government is urged to heed this call for action to uphold international law and address human rights concerns in the region.