Survivors Demand Inquiry into Decades of Abuse in Irish Asylums

UPDATE: Former patients of psychiatric asylums in Ireland are urgently calling for an inquiry and compensation over alleged systemic abuse spanning from the 1950s to the early 2000s. This shocking revelation comes as survivors recount harrowing experiences, including inhumane treatments and neglect, that have left lasting scars on their lives and families.

Mary Donovan, whose mother Margaret Mary was institutionalized for over 50 years, passionately stated, “Give them the apology and compensation that they deserve.” Donovan’s mother endured harsh treatments, including being strapped to a chair for extended periods, which Mary described as “absolutely inhumane.”

Survivor David Sugrue, now 67, recalls the terror of being placed in an adult psychiatric ward at just 14 years old. His account of being forcibly subjected to electroconvulsive therapy (ECT) without proper consent adds to the growing call for accountability from the Health Service Executive (HSE).

The need for transparency is urgent; with over 20,000 patients documented in more than 20 mental hospitals by the late 1950s, many families are now grappling with the devastating impact on their loved ones. “What wrong did a 16-year-old girl deserve to be locked away in an asylum?” asks Donovan, referencing her mother’s traumatic experience that began in 1955.

Recent testimonies reveal the depth of suffering endured. Mary Smith described her brother Christopher’s physical deterioration during his decades-long detention, stating, “He went from being a big man… to a skeleton.” Records indicate Christopher was never formally certified during his stay, raising serious questions about the legality of his detention.

Experts like Brendan Kelly, a professor of psychiatry at Trinity College Dublin, emphasize the historical context, noting that while mass institutionalization declined through the 1970s and 1980s, serious issues persisted. “Systematic institutionalization declined, but serious challenges with care remained,” he explained.

The HSE has issued a statement acknowledging the testimonies shared, expressing regret for the negative experiences faced by patients. However, critics argue that the government’s response has been insufficient. Sinn Féin’s spokesperson for mental health, Sorca Clarke, insists that the systemic failures must be recognized, stating, “The government has often framed this as being bad actors within certain institutions.”

Calls for an official inquiry are intensifying. Survivors and advocates emphasize the need for an urgent investigation to uncover the full extent of the abuses. “They have absolutely been sidelined, but maybe now it’s their time,” said Dr. Louise Rooney from Mental Health Reform, highlighting the importance of giving a voice to those who have suffered in silence.

Mary Donovan remains resolute: “I will keep fighting, and I will keep talking about her story, because what you did to her was wrong.” The emotional impact of these revelations cannot be overstated; families are still grappling with the pain of lost years and the trauma of their loved ones’ experiences.

As this story develops, the demand for justice grows louder. The call for an inquiry is not just a plea for acknowledgment; it is a vital step toward healing for countless survivors and their families who have endured unimaginable suffering. The urgency for action is clear, and the world is watching as these brave individuals seek the justice they deserve.